Sunday, November 15, 2015

Hoosier Hell House

This may not be a chilling ghost story set in the rural corn fields of Indiana but it is a tale of terror about the horror show that has been the macabre process of selling our seemingly doomed Indiana home. It's been quite awhile since I last updated our relocation journal, and that is because the story was just too depressing to commit to even the ephemeral pages of a blog.



We are on our third buyer (as in we accepted two previous offers that fell through at various points of the sale process) and we were originally set to close on November 1st after accepting their offer in late September. We had completed all buyer requests for repairs and improvements by October 24th and we had our offer accepted on a home in Montana we fell in love with and we set our MT closing date for November 16th (which I thought was MORE than enough padding).

Right after we completed work, we scheduled flights, arranged temporary lodging, and prepared for the movers to come and pack the entire household. Sometime in this process, we are informed there is a back-up offer on the house in MT we want. But who cares, right?

The tractor trailer and car transporters arrive October 30th, two days before we're supposed to close. While the team is loading our household goods, the VA appraiser for the buyers show up... which is not a good sign since there are no business days left to process this appraisal. The day gets worse since after our cars were picked up for shipping and enroute to Northwest Montana and 80% of our household goods were loaded on a tractor trailer, we were notified that the buyers had to extend closing until November 10th because their lender would not be able to complete underwriting in time due to not scheduling the appraisal sooner.

Bad timing, we had so much money wrapped up in the actual relocation of our personal property and ourselves, that it would have been financially devastating to pull the plug. So on November 1st, my father and I haul my Scout behind our other remaining vehicle and bring my dog along (because I couldn't find a reasonable way to fly her out). Late that night a tire loses tread on the car dolly, but luckily had a spare and we caught it before it blew. Ten minutes to change it and we're back on the road.

Then on November 2nd, as planned, my wife and daughter fly out to Montana and check into our [not-so] temporary lodging. That same afternoon. the other dolly tire goes in the middle of nowhere North Dakota. It was an adventure finding cell signal and locating the closest tire service to come mount two new tires, but we got it done fairly quickly and back on our journey west. We only lost about an hour and a half.



November 3rd I arrive in Montana and soon after look for storage for the Scout and dolly so we don't have to pull it around everywhere we need to go in the Tundra until our other vehicles arrive. On November 5th, we have our belongings sent to a warehouse for storage but take delivery of our vehicles. Our vehicles introduce a new wrinkle because they arrive with only flimsy copies of their keys and without the keyless entry transmitters because the originals were lost somewhere... and no one in the custody chain will admit responsibility (or explain how they were able to make duplicates).

November 10th comes and goes and no closing so we take matters into our own hands and begin contacting the buyers' lender directly. It was mostly my wife, because I was so angry and frustrated that I probably would have blown the entire deal. We discover that the buyers were displeased with their percentage rates and decided to consolidate their debt by taking out not one, but two additional loans after they had been pre-approved for their mortgage. This required their lender to completely re-evaluate their debt:income.

They finally get (re)approved Wednesday morning (November 11th), but because they took so long, their rate lock expired and due to new laws from October, there is now a mandatory 3 business day waiting period. Which means they want to close on the 16th, which means we wouldn't close on the Montana home (because we need my VA eligibility restored by the purchase of our Indiana home).

We do our own search and discover that the mandatory three day waiting period can be waived for hardship purposes, so we explain to the buyers' lender that if we don't close on Friday the 13th (of course it is!) then we won't get our home in here in the Rockies (due to the back-up offer that we were told the seller is ready to take because its better than ours). This approach fails, because it must be the buyers' hardship not the sellers'... so we inform them our hardship will become their hardship because if we can't close, they won't close since we'll scuttle the entire deal. They immediately draft a hardship letter and submit it.

Thursday morning we were informed the buyers' hardship letter was approved and I try to set closing for early AM Friday, but hey, one of the sellers has to work until the afternoon, because you know, closing on your house after all this struggle isn't important enough to request off work. I manage to get our side of things, and everything else but the buyers' signatures scheduled to be processed for Friday morning and the buyers set to finish early in the afternoon.

Because we didn't have enough time left for the VA and our own lender to process my eligibility, we had to push our Montana close date back to the 18th (luckily, I noticed there was a clause in our contract that said we have a 5 day grace period if we're having issues getting our loan) and I also manage to swing a free extension because now my own rate lock is going to expire.



We finally got confirmation Friday evening that the sale was complete and we saw that the bank has processed the purchased and marked our first mortgage as paid in full. The VA still hasn't cleared my eligibility, but I'm hoping that the official documentation of the purchase is all we need to close on our new home. Things are finally beginning to fall in place. In the meantime, I'm going to watch these dark clouds float past the beautiful Swan Mountain range.

Monday, August 24, 2015

Wildfire Worries

Over the last month or so, wildfires have been raging in the West (mostly California, Oregon, Washington, Idaho, & Montana. I've been following the local news at our relocation destination in Kalispell for a while now and I keep seeing warnings about unhealthy air quality in Flathead Valley. This does give me some cause for concern.

Wildfire at Glacier National Park


Who knows when this drought will end or if we're seeing something more akin to what might be the new norm due to climate change. These concerns are toiling away in the back of my mind and I wonder if I want to invest in property that could easily be wiped out by raging fires in the near future. Also, one of the reasons I'm moving is to experience the clean mountain air... which is currently choked with smoke.

Smoke blotting the Sun, credit: Emily Graves Johnson Charlo


I hope the landscape will eventually heal, but with global warming, I have to give consideration to the idea that perhaps there isn't likely going to be a reprieve anytime soon. Regardless, we need to sell the house before we can move anywhere.


REFERENCES

Thursday, August 20, 2015

Hoosier Home Listed!

First big milestone, our current (or old/previous home depending on when you read this) has finally been listed. After two months of small improvements to put our best foot forward, we finally brought the realtor out to take pictures and put it up for sale.

So far, it's been listed for less than 24 hours and we have already had two showings and four more scheduled through this week. We also have an offer from a property management group, albeit fairly low-ball. We're hoping this is a sign of good things to come and that hopefully we'll get our asking price!

Front of House, Looking East/Southeast
So, if you are looking for a house in the Indianapolis area, or know someone who is, please share and take a look.

MIBOR
Zillow
Trulia
Redfin
Homes
Metro Indy Pros Site

Home Details:


  • Franklin, Indiana (about 25 minutes south of Indianapolis)
  • List price: $130,000
  • 3 Bedrooms
  • 2 Bathrooms
  • 2 Unfinished Bonus Rooms
  • About 1560 sqft Finished Main Floor, 500+ sqft. Unfinished Upstairs
  • 2 Car Garage
  • .28 Acre Corner Lot
  • Fenced Backyard
  • Playset
  • Shed
  • Mature Trees
  • Alarm System
  • Brand New Stainless French Door Refrigerator & Dishwasher
  • Cathedral Ceiling in Living Room
  • 3/4" Hardwood floors
  • Custom Trim
  • Newly Painted Interior
Below are some more pictures from the listing along with the area their relative location and additional details to get a feel for the layout.
Living Room, Looking Northwest Into Front Door, Closet, Bedroom 2, & Hallway to Guest Bath & Bedroom 3

Living Room, Cathedral Ceiling, Looking East Into Kitchen & Patio Door

Kitchen, East, Looking Into Hallway To Master Bedroom & Utility Room

Kitch, East, Looking Into Living Room

Master Bedroom, Southeast, Left Door Leading to Master Bath, Right Door To Hallway to Utility Room, Kitchen, & Living Room

Master Bath, Southwest, Door Leading to Master Bedroom

Guest Bath, North

Bedroom 2, Northwest

Bedroom 3, Northeast

Utility Room Leading to Garage

West Bonus Room Over Garage

Backyard, Facing Northeast

Backyard, Facing Southeast

Monday, August 10, 2015

The Long Internet Home Search

Been a long while since I updated. For the last month or so, I have been in full-on house project mode, doing things like fresh paint, flooring, and landscaping to put our current home's best foot forward when we place it on the market (so if anyone is interested in a 3 bedroom home on the southern outskirts of Indianapolis [Franklin], or know someone who might be interested let me know).

Now that the facelift mania has passed, we're beginning to work with our realtor in Montana to narrow down the areas and types of homes we're interested in. Which brings us to the awesome, yet frustrating endeavor of long-distance window-shopping for homes.

There are some very cool internet resources for long distance (and local) home shopping. Zillow, Trulia, and Realtor are probably most well known sites. For those exploring FSBO [For Sale By Owner], there are local classified sites or Craigslist. But there are also local realty organizations that provide search tools as well. Central Indiana has MIBOR [Metropolitan Indianapolis Board of REALTORS] and northwest Montana has NMAR [Northwest Montana Association of REALTORS].

NMAR


Yet, none of them are perfect. You'll find different information for the same listing across all the sites or even the same site (when there are multiple listings for the same property).

Trulia


My primary gripe with Trulia is that I cannot specify large regions to search. What would be great is if it allowed state, multiple zip code, or map-based searching. Perhaps most people know they will be confined to a particular zip code for work purposes, but I have far more freedom. I want to be able to see all the places within the region that matches my criteria. Also, I'd like to have more granular control over criteria than what is provided by the default values in the drop-downs. Internet availability, tax information, and other details seem to be sparse or non-existent.

Zillow


I feel that Zillow is somewhat better than Trulia at the MLS game. Along with Trulia, it is an MLS aggregator that may or may not have the latest or reliable information about a listing (such as if the home is on contract or already sold). But it does allow searching by map or by an entire state, which is why I like it more that Trulia. I really wish it had overlays for internet and cell service so you could see where coverage was. Also, I really like the instant-notification for saved searches.

Realtor


Realtor.com has best detailed information and granular search options of all the big aggregator sites, but I hate its image viewer. Trulia and Zillow definitely have better presentation. Another gripe I have with Realtor.com is that even though I can save and rate homes, I wish there were folders I could publicly share so my wife and realtor could view them.

NMAR


This regional site is by far my preferred MLS shopping utility. You can share searches (and selected homes from a search) to permanent links that can be accessed by anyone. The level of details for searches is by far the best. I can actually search for homes that have "high speed internet" and have between 1643 & 2978 square feet and have (mountain views or water frontage or trees). Of course, we're assuming the listing agent supplied all this information accurately, but still, I love the search. You can zoom in on the map to limit your results and it utilizes tabs to separate views (list, detail, photos, map). When in the photo tab, it presents big slideshows and allows the user to use the up & down keys to move between the sorted listings from the search, while the left & right keys allow you to move between pics of the home. Which allows you to quickly determine interest level in the homes. If there was a hot key to "select" a home, it would be perfect.

I do wish I could create an account to save searches, receive notifications, and manage saved homes, but I just keep the window open and refresh it throughout the day.

Best MLS Search Features


If anyone is paying attention, I think the following features are must haves:
  • Map-based Search
  • State-wide, Multiple Zip Code Search
  • Numeric Entry for Search Fields
    • price
    • square footage
    • acreage
  • Internet/Cell Coverage Map Overlays
    • heat mapped by speed, network type
  • Feature Search
    • terrain/waterfront
    • views
    • style/construction type
    • age
    • HOA/covenants
    • taxes
    • utilities/internet
    • appliances included
    • road class/surface
    • adjacent owners
    • outbuildings/fencing
    • luxury items (fireplace, hot tub, etc.)
  • Full-screen Image Viewer
  • Saved Searches
    • notifications of new/updated homes
    • shared searches
  • Saved Homes
    • folders
    • shared folders
  • Easy Navigation
    • hot keys

Reconnaissance


No long-distance home search would be complete without gather intel on the local area. Places to eat; things to see; activities to enjoy. We've used the city's website,  Google Maps (Street View & Views in particular are great tools), Yelp, Foursquare, CitySearch, and even various blogs & forums (Redditcity-data.com).

House Hunting Trip


We're maintaining a short list of homes we like until we get some traction with the sale of our current home. Once we feel we're in a good position with the sale, we're going to schedule a week to go out and meet our Montana realtor and visit our list of potential future homes.

Monday, June 15, 2015

Montanan Xenophobia

Before we decided to make the trek to Montana, I did some research to see what problems, hurdles, and obstacles we might encounter during a relocation. I frequently came across lists of reasons why people should not move to Big Sky Country. The reasons are always some form of "you can't hack frontier life." It's too cold, there's too much snow, you'll get eaten by bears, trampled by moose, bitten by snakes, or chewed on by some grizzled mountain man. If it is not fearmongering about the dangers of the wild west, it's a frank warning about economic depression and a lack of employment. Sometimes it's just plain unhospitality, "Get off my lawn!" This is in sharp contrast to a recent Gallop poll where Montanans (along with Alaskans) rated their state the best place to live in the US.

Clearcutting makes me sad...

Ever Encroaching Horde of Humanity


I understand it. There are definitely plenty of city slickers who could get themselves or others killed with their lack of respect for untamed mother nature. Then there are the rich elite who have managed to drive up real estate prices and create expansive, private fiefdoms that rail against the Montanan culture of accessible public land. From my experience, Montanans embrace the outdoor lifestyle; it's very similar to the Scandinavian concept of friluftsliv. More people mean less wild which erodes the very reasons everyone loves Montana.

I mourn the loss of empty spaces even here in the midwest. I'd much rather see fields of corn and soybeans than claustrophobic, cookie-cutter subdivisions. It really cuts my psyche to see trees felled under the chainsaws of ever-encroaching hordes of humanity.

Artist Concept of an Arcology

Part of the Problem?


Does my relocation make me part of the problem? Should humanity just be bunched together and stacked atop each other? I totally think more urban areas should invest in the concept of the tall arcology that embraces architectural design principals of densely populated habitats. The planet could also benefit from hastening the trend of smaller families (and maybe free vasectomies and contraception).

I certainly hope I'm not part of the problem. I just don't feel like I belong in the midwest. I yearn for the dense pines, tall mountains, and sparsely populated areas of western Montana. Perhaps I can become an advocate for the conservation of the untamed lands I anticipate living in as penance for daring to call the last best place my home.

Additional Reading




Monday, June 8, 2015

An Ode to Minimalism (Or I Wish I Could Pack Less)

One of our first steps in the process to relocate to Montana was to purge our current possessions of things we no longer wanted or needed. Even though we have an entire garage of things to sell, donate, and recycle, I know I'm still clinging to belongings that I could live without. Even though I take pride on being able to deprogram myself of all the banality of decades of exposure to commercial messaging and misguided cultural mores (which transmogrify the masses from common imbeciles to compliant sheeple), I feel like I cannot shake the need to surround myself with material possessions.

No, my accumulation is not this bad...

Motivations for Material Wealth


After a little reflection, I think the cause behind material possession accumulation can mostly be boiled down to four motives:

  • Identity - Things that reflect your interests, values, passions, and self.
  • Prestige - Things that influence others' impression of your self worth.
  • Sentiment - Things that trigger fond memories of loved ones or personal experience.
  • Utility - Things we use to accomplish some task.
Certainly there is overlap between these motivations, maybe that antique La Cornue range you inherited from your great-grandmother is a source of identity because you aspire to be a culinary master, while it is also a famous marque worth tens of thousands of dollars making your kitchen very prestigious, not mention all the memories of preparing dinner for the family with four generations of women from your family... and hey, it works perfect for everyday meals too!

I think I have a good handle on half of the motivations, but I admit that I have an issue with collecting (identity) and then everything people have given me for those collections also makes them sentimental. It doesn't help to think that maybe my daughter might also get some use out of these collections as she gets older (mostly books and games).

Still, I believe I have made progress. I have finally let go of reams of magazines whose pages I've barely touched since picking them off the newsstand, yet manage to carry around with me for the last fifteen years. Mountains of books that are no longer relevant are gone. I still have a sizable library, but at least it is not overflowing any longer. I've shed about half of wardrobe. I've also managed to expunge enough electronics that they could repurpose the silicon to build a dozen Deep Blues.

Tiny Home Inspirations
Tiny Home  Mountain Cottage


I'm inspired by the Tiny Home Movement, though I'm not under any allusions about achieving such a thing until our daughter goes to college. Still, it is something to aspire to. Reducing our footprint and banishing all the things that keep us shackled inside so we can live outside more is definitely an ethos that compliments our destination in Big Sky Country. Still, I guess we'll need a few things to keep us occupied during the long winters.

Additional Reading

The Minimalists - It's not about having less, it's about making room for more [life].
The Tiny Life - Simple living, tiny homes, & environmentally responsible lifestyles

Monday, June 1, 2015

Oro y Plata


Gold & Silver. It's Montana's official state motto (translated from Spanish 'Oro y Plata') and its akin to the treasure I found in my inbox at work. The relocation benefits package I inquired about was an attachment in a recent email. It sat there while I was trapped in a meeting, flirting with my desire to migrate to the mountains.

When I finally was free, and my mental defenses prepped for disappointment, I opened the titillating document. The generosity astonished me. The relocation package would cover the packing, shipping, temporary storage, and unpacking of pretty much all our household goods with the exception of ammunition and plants. It would provide transit of two vehicles and pay for a week of house hunting (including travel, accommodations, meals, and incidentals), two months of temporary housing, airfare for a one-way ticket there, and even provide a realtor program for selling and buying. I have a little over a year to make things happen.

Previously, while saluting Saleforce for providing employees with relocation packages because of the RFRA, I mentioned how a relocation package could alleviate at least one of our four difficulties of long distance relocation. However, this package is generous enough to practically alleviate three of our concerns.
  • Time off, travel, and accommodations are required during house hunting
    • Remote house hunting is a dodgey affair, even with excellent sites like Zillow.
  • Long-distance job hunting is difficult
    • Especially when we are living in a two-income age
  • Logistics with coordinating sale and purchases can be expensive
    • Household storage is difficult and expensive or you have two mortgages
  • Timing can be delicate
    • Windows of opportunity for both good weat
The remaining concern is relegated to being half as potent as it would be for people with traditional jobs since I now work remotely anyways. My wife will begin searching for another gig once we narrow down exactly where we will be living. She is a social worker and she is interested in serving the needs of reservations, which Montana has in spades.

There is one more caveat, I will need a reliable internet connection for my work. I'm not familiar with the broadband services available in Montana, their coverage, or if satellite internet would suffice. These are all questions we will have to find answers for before we give real estate any real consideration. 

Monday, May 25, 2015

Determining Our Destination

The family resolved to expatriate from Indiana, but to where? I had established a list of potential places to move to a long time ago:
  • Norway 
  • New Zealand 
  • Denmark 
  • Iceland 
  • Canada 
Unfortunately, my wife kiboshed those locations with what felt like unabashed glee. She quickly pointed out that the burden would be fairly significant to find a home, find a job (at least for her, since I work remotely), assimilate into the culture (we agreed it would be rude to not learn the language & customs), obtain visas and/or renounce our citizenship and apply for another. I mentioned Canada is pretty close in language (assuming we wouldn't live in Quebec) and culture, but I just got a cross look and was told think about how much this will affect our daughter.

Thus, our choice was confined to the United States of America. Which is fine, there are many things about the States that I love: the landscapes, the history, the Constitution, the diversity, the landscapes. Yes, I mentioned landscapes twice, the United States encompasses quite a varied terrain and even managed to protect some of the spectacular locations in the world despite the nature of Americans. Of course, there is plenty to dislike: the history, the violence, the hate, the politics. Yes, history is on both lists; we've accomplished great things and great, terrible things.

1st Priority: More Privacy


One of our priorities in determining our relocation destination was that we wanted a buffer of moderate isolation. We are not talking Antarctica bunker level isolation, just that I would prefer if I cannot see my neighbors' domiciles or hear loud music reverberating from vehicles driven by angst-ridden adolescents. Basically, we want to hinder the ability of people to interfere with our lives. We have encountered neighbors (and family) pressuring us about our lack of religious convictions (or rather my conviction to lack religion), constant political solicitations, and let's not forget the endless stream of bible pushers.

My family tends to get a greater share of godbotherers than most others due to the fact that my wife was indoctrinated into the church of Latter Day Saints as a child. The mormons are a perpetual peturbation as they make their monthly pilgrimage to petition my wife to return to their pews. There doesn't seem to be an end to their pestering, and now we get mail from the snowbird wife of the local ward's bishop while she's in Florida. We've met a lack of enthusiasm from the local police about enforcing any kind of restraint (was actually told that it would be tough to restrain an entire organization 'that has good intentions').

We understand that while rural locations tend to be more conservative, there are also less people to be concerned about. The further one lives away from a population center, the less likely some missionary on a bicycle will be knocking at the door, or anyone for that matter. Besides, we enjoy nature and I look forward to serenity the wilderness affords.

2nd Priority: Less Hate


Indiana's legalized discrimination bill thinly veiled under the guise of freedom was the last straw for our family. Watching people we know, even friends and family, scurry to the defense of the loathsome legislation was like watching an intrusion of cockroaches devour rotten garbage. It was despicable and revolting (and actually offensive to cockroaches everywhere). It's ludicrous to think that in America's current socio-political climate there is a "safe" place for progressive minds to live, but there has to be something better than the rusty bible belt. Even California, often lauded as a bastion of progressiveness, has Prop 8 and the murderous Sodomite Suppression Act.

We looked at historical legislation, recent legislation, as well as testimonies from people we know living in relatively uncongested areas, particularly the west coast (California, Oregon, & Washington) and some other states we have personally visited that we liked (Wyoming, Montana, & Idaho). Idaho and Wyoming were knocked out pretty fast by virtue of their backwards politics. Massive drought and the high cost of living crossed California off the list. Oregon was dropped from the list because we couldn't find anywhere we particularly liked and knew no one who lived there. That left Washington and Montana (my wife reminds of Hawaii, but that place is also too expensive).

This article offers an amazing summary of what we were looking for in terms of legislation. The perception of Montana is that of ultra conservative. Yet, they recently defeated their own RFRA bill (no courts or national shaming involved) and have a history of being socially liberal while holding a libertarian points of view. Montana gave women full suffrage 6 years before the ratification of the 19th Amendment and then elected the first woman to congress in four years before it was passed (it started by giving women the right to vote in school related elections back when it was a territory in 1887). It’s the 3rd state to recognize the right to die. And it tried to defy the Citizens United decision by SCOTUS (not directly related to civil rights, but in order to get representatives that will make the right decision, we need to get money out of politics).

3rd Priority: Affordable & Enjoyable Property


We really loved Washington politics, but my wife is not a fan of the gloomy, rain-soaked reputation west of the Cascades, and much of the stuff east is either super-expensive islands of awesome or barren high-altitude wasteland (or at least that is the impression we get from the real estate pics and has been confirmed by our acquaintances there).

We sampled pricing on current offerings on real estate in areas we would be willing to relocate to, keeping in mind our desire to stay away from suburbia, Montana won out in availability of affordable homes (and gorgeous vistas!). We recently took a vacation to Montana and fell in love with Big Sky country. The many peaks of soaring granite calls out to my inner Muir, the mountains are calling and I must go.



There are jerks everywhere, but it feels like they are concentrated in the Bible Belt and much of the Midwest and any movement away from humidity and corn would likely yield an improvement. I have had it with this place and my sanity requires some place new. I have a hundred anecdotes of our personal dealings with fundamentalists that reside in Indiana (and about the same number from my time in the Marine Corps) and realize that utopia does not exist, but just maybe, we can find a place where the population density, and therefore the asshole density, is a lot less.

Additional Reading


Monday, May 18, 2015

Salesforce Extends Relocation Benefits to Hoosiers?


Salesforce CEO, Marc Benioff, stated that he was giving employees money to relocate due to sentiments around the RFRA. $50,000 relocation packages to be specific. Even after the Religious Freedom Restoration Act language was amended, with strong input from people like Marc, Salesforce still supported Hoosier employees who still did not feel welcome by the state. A feeling I share, and have long felt being an atheist living in Indiana. Hoosier Hospitality is great, if you're straight and white and christian.
A $50k relocation package is beyond generous, though to clarify, a relocation package is not simply handing a lump sum to employees, but it does alleviate a lot of the expenses generated during a relocation (house-finding trips, travel, moving household good, shipping vehicles, and possibly realtor costs associated with selling & buying a home).

Difficulties of Long Distance Relocation

One of the few reasons my family has not already relocated out of the rust belt is the cost involved in moving a great distance:
  • Time off, travel, and accommodations are required during house hunting
    • Remote house hunting is a dodgey affair, even with excellent sites like Zillow.
  • Long-distance job hunting is difficult
    • Especially when we are living in a two-income age
  • Logistics with coordinating sale and purchases can be expensive
    • Household storage is difficult and expensive or you have two mortgages
  • Timing can be delicate
    • Windows of opportunity for both good weather as well as mitigating the interruption of the education of a child is relatively small
A relocation package could help alleviate at least one of those bullet points and possibly another depending on how generous the services available with the package are (such as realtor assistance).


Additional Reading

Monday, May 11, 2015

Religious Bigotry Imposition Act

Humanity Devolved


Oppress. Ostracize. Persecute. Humanity's vulgar response to different, often deployed in tandem with more violent reactions of Maim, Kill, and Destroy. The sciences of evolution, sociology, and psychology tells us that these base, animalistic urges to discriminate against people who do not conform to our limited definition of normal are vestiges of behaviors that enabled our burgeoning species to survive the myriad dangers of the wilderness.

This aversion to the unknown, and fear of what may be lurking in that endless oblivion, is fine when when you're worried about fangs and talons in the darkness coming to eat you or your primitive offspring. However, in modern, civilized society, such inclinations towards our fellow humans are extraordinarily malapropos. Logic and tolerance should prevail, yet hate and discrimination still lurk in the shadows of our society and occasionally gain enough agency to reveal their ugly visages and run rampant in public.

Today's burning issue that unleashes the beasts of hate from their tenebrous lair is sexual orientation, followed closely by gender identity. However, it's not as if we've graduated beyond misogyny or racism; we have just managed hide it better. Tomorrow's issue will most likely deal with the rise of non-belief; miraculously bringing christian fanatics and muslim zealots together to vomit forth acrimony in a cacophony of hate. In Indiana, the barking and howling of the hate beast has manifested as the Religion Freedom Restoration Act.

A Solution in Search of a Problem


The Indiana ACLU called out the RFRA as a "solution in search of a problem" which is an accurate description of a bill whose namesake suggests religious freedom has been lost. The only thing religion has lost in the in the last year is its unconstitutional tyranny to impose itself on Hoosiers who didn't conform to a limited interpretation of marriage from an antiquated and often self-contradictory mythology written by goat-herders thousands of years ago.

When SCotUS declined to hear the appeal of the circuit court rulings that struck down gay marriage bans for Indiana and four other states in October of 2014, marriage equality became law. This places the context of the drafting of the Indiana RFRA firmly in the domain of retaliation and sends a message that "it's acceptable to discriminate against LGBT people."

The defenders of this bill point out that there is a federal version signed into law by Clinton, yet there is additional language that changes the intent of the bill to keep citizens' religious freedoms from becoming burdened by government interference to allowing citizens to protect themselves from civil litigation from other citizens for their own discriminatory actions by using this Act as their defense.

Besides, the federal act has several unintended consequences ranging from denial of housing to unmarried couples (used as defense against the violation of fair housing laws) to thwarting the criminal investigation of polygamous fundamentalist mormons who force twelve-year-olds into marriage. The additional language introduced in the Indiana RFRA bill would open the door for a much broader range of [un]intended consequences. The wording of the [unamended] RFRA would clearly encourage rampant discrimination against not only LGBT, but anyone for any reason.

This legislation was not about protecting people's religious freedoms, it was about protecting privilege, the status quo, and people's comfort level. Jim Crow on steroids.

Bad for Business


Fortunately, a business with a strong local presence and a history of promoting social justice quickly began applying pressure, which started a trend of local and distant businesses and government entities to do the same. The CEO of Salesforce Marketing Cloud,  along with its parent company, Salesforce.com, issued strong objections to the RFRA and began shutting down non-essential business travel to the state and vowed to halt expansions. This act cascaded as many local businesses and entities such as Lilly, NCAA, Cummins, and Angie's List began throwing their weight around. The city of Indianapolis even issued statements and railed against this enshrinement of discrimination.

The pressure ended up making a difference with amended language being accepted and quickly passed by the state government, who had been shamed and berated at a national level. They all plead innocence for their motives, but the context couldn't have been more clear and they were trying to save face under the national spotlight.

Pyrrhic Victory


We won the battle, but I'm withdrawing from the war. Or at least abandoning this particular theater/front, I still hear people I know, even family members, complain about how their religious liberties are being stripped away. I'm tired of pointing out that their liberty is intact and only their ability to impose their religion on others has been impeded. I'm also tired of that look of disbelief or rage that immediately follows my reminder. It happens all too often around these amber waves of grain.

Additional Reading


Monday, May 4, 2015

The Crossroads of America

Indiana State Seal; It's missing a bible...
I was at a crossroads. I was born in Indiana, raised in Indiana, and with the exception of four honorable years of service with the United States Marine Corps, resided in Indiana for nearly four decades. My wife is a native Hoosier and, obviously, so is our daughter. However, my capacity for observing and enduring general asininity and specific bigotry of my neighbors and fellow Hoosiers had been depleted.

The neighbors we have in close proximity were swell, and they should not be confused with the miscreants I bear your attention towards. These neighbors aside, I was surrounded by racists, chauvinists, xenophobes, and homophobes. All these collections of misanthropes seemed to intersect each other and reside within the religious zealot super set. The Venn diagram of ecclesiastical jackassery.

My gullet was stretched and sore from years of being force-fed chapter and verse from a book out of time and therefore unpalatable to my modern, logical gustation. The fatigue from being exposed to my Raised Right Republican peers permeated my psyche so deeply that I could think of only one salve for the injury from all those peremptory psalms: relocation.

A displacement of sorts was required to remove my family from the mouth frothing hate, legally enshrined discrimination, and the dark ugliness that tends to develop among dense deposits of humanity: a shift in position far from the judgment of the bible belt. I decided to escape to a venue where there were less people, less imposition & inquisition, and more natural harmony. I knew it would be difficult to accomplish, but I was determined to make it happen.

This site is journal of that struggle.